In short
19 U.S.C. §1592 is the core civil penalty statute CBP uses when goods are entered with a material false statement or a material omission. The penalty depends on culpability: negligence (up to twice the lost duties), gross negligence (up to four times), or fraud (up to the domestic value of the goods). CBP’s published guidelines then set a narrower range for settlement, and lost duties must be paid on top. A valid prior disclosure, made before CBP starts a formal investigation, can reduce a negligence case to interest only.
What §1592 prohibits
No person may, by fraud, gross negligence or negligence, enter or introduce, or attempt to enter or introduce, merchandise into U.S. commerce by means of a material false document, electronic data, statement or act, or a material omission, or aid or abet someone else in doing so (19 U.S.C. §1592(a)(1)). This applies whether or not the United States actually lost any duty.
Three words do most of the work:
- Material. A statement or omission is material if it has a natural tendency to influence, or is capable of influencing, CBP’s action. A “but for” link to lost duty is not required (19 C.F.R. part 171, Appendix B (B)). Value, classification, origin, quantity, the identity of the importer, and admissibility facts are typical examples.
- False or omitted. Undervalued invoices, unreported assists or royalties, a wrong country of origin, transshipment, a misdescribed product, or a missing antidumping declaration can all qualify.
- Clerical error. A clerical error or mistake of fact is not a violation unless it is part of a pattern of negligent conduct, and the automatic repetition of one keying error by a computer system does not by itself create a pattern (§1592(a)(2)).
Three levels of culpability
CBP’s guidelines define them (Appendix B (C)):
- Negligence: failing to exercise reasonable care and competence to make sure statements are correct, for example, not checking the classification of a new product or not asking how the supplier’s price was built.
- Gross negligence: acting with actual knowledge of, or wanton disregard for, the relevant facts and with indifference to the obligations under the law.
- Fraud: a material false statement, omission or act committed knowingly, that is, deliberately.
The label is the single most important issue in most cases, because it sets both the ceiling and the settlement range.
The statutory maximums
| Culpability | If duties were lost | If no duty was lost |
|---|---|---|
| Negligence | Lesser of the domestic value or 2× the lost duties, taxes and fees | 20% of the dutiable value |
| Gross negligence | Lesser of the domestic value or 4× the lost duties, taxes and fees | 40% of the dutiable value |
| Fraud | Domestic value of the merchandise | Domestic value of the merchandise |
Source: 19 U.S.C. §1592(c)(1)–(3). “Domestic value” is roughly the U.S. wholesale market value of the goods, which is often much higher than the declared customs value.
How CBP actually sets the amount: the mitigation guidelines
The statutory maximum is rarely the final number. When CBP decides a case, its guidelines provide these ranges (Appendix B (F)(2)), all capped at the domestic value:
| Culpability | Duty-loss cases | Non-duty-loss cases |
|---|---|---|
| Negligence | 0.5× to 2× the total loss of duty | 5% to 20% of dutiable value |
| Gross negligence | 2.5× to 4× the total loss of duty | 25% to 40% of dutiable value |
| Fraud | 5× to 8× the total loss of duty | 50% to 80% of dutiable value |
Where a case lands within the range depends on mitigating and aggravating factors (Appendix B (G), (H)).
Mitigating factors include contributory CBP error, extraordinary cooperation, immediate remedial action (such as paying the lost duties before or within 30 days of the penalty notice), inexperience in importing (not for fraud or gross negligence), a prior good record (not for fraud), and documented inability to pay.
Aggravating factors include obstructing an investigation, withholding evidence, misleading CBP, prior §1592 violations, textile transshipment, a motive to evade a prohibition or restriction, and ignoring a records demand or summons. Aggravating factors cannot raise the level of culpability; they offset mitigating factors.
Technical violations that are not tied to the value of the goods carry fixed amounts: $1,000 to $2,000 for a first violation of that kind, and $2,000 to $10,000 for multiple or repeated violations (Appendix B (E)).
Lost duties come on top
Whatever happens to the penalty, CBP must require that lost duties, taxes and fees be restored (§1592(d)). A mitigated penalty is normally conditioned on paying the actual loss of duty. Paying it early also counts as remedial action.
Prior disclosure: the most valuable tool
If you disclose the circumstances of a violation before, or without knowledge of, the commencement of a formal investigation, and tender the lost duties, the penalty is capped (§1592(c)(4); 19 C.F.R. §162.74):
- Negligence or gross negligence: interest on the lost duties, from liquidation to the date of payment. With no actual loss, no penalty.
- Fraud: 100% of the lost duties; if no duty was lost, 10% of the dutiable value.
The rules are strict. The disclosure must identify the merchandise, the entries (or ports and approximate dates), the false statements or omissions and how they happened, and the correct information, with anything still unknown supplied within 30 days (§162.74(b)). An oral disclosure must be confirmed in writing within 10 days (§162.74(a)(2)). The money may be tendered with the disclosure or within 30 days after CBP sends its calculation (§162.74(c)).
Timing is everything. A formal investigation begins on the date CBP records in writing that it had reason to believe a violation may have occurred (§162.74(g)). You are presumed to know about it if, for example, CBP has told you the type of violation, a Special Agent has asked about it or requested specific records, a pre-penalty notice has issued, or the goods were seized (§162.74(i)). Once that happens, the door usually closes for that issue.
Worked numbers
Suppose an importer underpaid $100,000 in duties over two years, and the goods have a domestic value of $1.5 million.
| Scenario | Statutory maximum | Guideline range |
|---|---|---|
| Negligence | $200,000 | $50,000 to $200,000 |
| Gross negligence | $400,000 | $250,000 to $400,000 |
| Fraud | $1,500,000 | $500,000 to $800,000 |
| Negligence, with valid prior disclosure | Interest on $100,000 only | |
In every row, the $100,000 itself must also be paid. This is an illustration of the arithmetic, not a prediction for any real case.
Who can be liable
The statute reaches any “person,” not only the importer of record. The Federal Circuit held that a company officer who personally introduced goods into commerce could be personally liable for a §1592 penalty in his own right (United States v. Trek Leather, Inc., 767 F.3d 1288 (Fed. Cir. 2014) (en banc)). Brokers, consultants and suppliers can also face liability, including for aiding and abetting (§1592(a)(1)(B)). Under CBP’s interim final rule on foreign importers of record, revised Appendix B paragraph (K), effective January 5, 2027, exposes customs brokers to §1592 penalties more broadly.
Limitation period, seizure and court
- Five years. The government must sue within five years of the violation, or, for fraud, within five years after discovering it (19 U.S.C. §1621). CBP often asks for a waiver of the statute to keep negotiating; take advice before signing one.
- Seizure. CBP may seize merchandise if it has reasonable cause to believe a violation occurred and the person is insolvent, beyond U.S. jurisdiction, or seizure is otherwise needed to protect the revenue (§1592(c)(14)). This is a real risk for foreign importers.
- Court. CBP cannot collect a penalty on its own. If you do not pay, the government must sue in the Court of International Trade, which decides everything, including the amount, de novo. For fraud the government must prove its case by clear and convincing evidence; for gross negligence it bears the burden on all elements; for negligence it proves the act or omission and the defendant must then show it was not negligent (§1592(e)).
What is changing
Executive Order 14411 (June 3, 2026) directs CBP to tighten mitigation, including a floor so that mitigated penalties are not below 50% of the assessed penalty and no mitigation for repeat violators. As of November 2026 CBP had not yet published revised guidelines on that point. If it does, prior disclosure becomes even more valuable, and early, accurate answers to CBP matter more.
Common questions
Can CBP penalize us if no duty was lost?
Yes. The statute applies whether or not duty was lost; the measure then becomes a percentage of dutiable value, such as a false origin statement on duty-free goods.
Our broker made the mistake. Are we off the hook?
Not automatically. The importer must use reasonable care. What you told the broker, and when, often decides whether the error counts as your negligence.
Should we disclose now or wait to see if CBP notices?
If you have found a real error and no investigation has begun, a prior disclosure usually costs far less than waiting. Get advice first on scope, sampling and how to describe the cause.
When to call a lawyer
When you find a pattern of errors in your entries, receive a CF-28 or CF-29 that touches value, origin or classification, or receive a pre-penalty notice. Attorney Cynthia Wu handles customs matters personally, in English and Mandarin, and is admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade. Phone consultations: (520) 358-5095 or book online.
Related: Received a §1592 penalty notice? Deadlines and how to respond · CF-28 and CF-29 · Executive Order 14411 tracker · CBP protests
Sources: 19 U.S.C. §§1592, 1621; 19 C.F.R. §162.74 and Appendix B to part 171; CBP Dec. 26-19, 91 FR 69977 (Nov. 6, 2026); Executive Order 14411; United States v. Trek Leather, Inc., 767 F.3d 1288 (Fed. Cir. 2014) (en banc). Current as of November 2026.
Attorney advertising. General information, not legal advice. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Part of the guide: CBP Detentions, Seizures and Penalties: A Guide for Importers

