Serving Los Angeles County, Orange County and clients nationwide · Phone consultations

Customs & trade

CBP Liquidated Damages Claims: What the Bond Notice Means, the 60-Day Petition, Amounts and What the Surety Will Do

In short

A CBP liquidated damages claim is a demand under your customs bond, not a fine. It arises when a bond condition is breached, for example a late entry summary, a missed redelivery, an unpaid duty deposit or a late Importer Security Filing. The amount is fixed by the bond conditions, often the value of the goods. The importer has 60 days from the date the notice is mailed to petition for relief, the surety is notified at the same time, and CBP has authority to cancel the claim for a lesser amount.

What a liquidated damages claim is

Almost every commercial importer files a customs bond, either a single transaction bond or a continuous bond. The bond is a contract. The importer (the principal) and a surety company promise CBP that the importer will do certain things: pay duties, file complete entry documents on time, return goods to CBP when asked, and follow the rules that apply to conditionally released goods. The law lets the Treasury set the conditions of the bond and the sums payable when they are breached (19 U.S.C. §1623(b)).

When a condition is breached, CBP does not need to prove negligence or fraud. It issues a notice of liquidated damages and a demand for payment to the principal, and notifies the surety at the same time (19 C.F.R. §172.1(a)). The notice usually comes on CBP Form 5955A from a Fines, Penalties and Forfeitures (FP&F) office. It must tell the principal that it may apply for relief (§172.1(b)).

This is different from a penalty under 19 U.S.C. §1592, which depends on a false statement or omission and on the importer’s level of fault. One set of facts can produce both, but the two are handled under different rules and on different clocks.

The bond conditions importers breach most often

The conditions of the basic importation and entry bond are in 19 C.F.R. §113.62. These produce most claims:

  • Depositing estimated duties on time (§113.62(a)(1)(i)). A default is presumed if a check is returned unpaid or an ACH payment is not transmitted on time (§113.62(n)(4)).
  • Filing the entry summary and documents on time when goods are released before entry is complete (§113.62(b); 19 C.F.R. §142.15).
  • Producing documents or evidence that were still missing at release (§113.62(c)).
  • Redelivering goods on demand when they turn out to be inadmissible, must be examined, or must be marked with their country of origin (§113.62(d)). CBP must make the demand no later than 30 days after release or 30 days after the end of the conditional release period, whichever is later.
  • Fixing an admissibility problem within the time set in CBP’s notice: marking, cleaning, fumigating, destroying or exporting the goods (§113.62(e)).
  • Holding goods intact at an outside examination site until CBP releases them (§113.62(f)).
  • Using duty-free or reduced-duty goods as claimed and proving it on time (§113.62(h)).
  • Importer Security Filing (ISF) and, where the importer has elected to file them, electronic advance cargo data (§113.62(j), (k)).

How much CBP can claim

Default Liquidated damages Source
Most defaults that involve merchandise (late or missing entry documents, failure to redeliver, failure to hold or fix the goods) The value of the merchandise involved 19 C.F.R. §113.62(n)(1)
Same, when the goods are restricted or prohibited merchandise or alcoholic beverages Three times the value §113.62(n)(1)
A default that does not involve merchandise $1,000 for each default §113.62(n)(3)
Estimated duties, taxes and charges not deposited on time (this default only) Two times the unpaid amount, or $1,000, whichever is greater §113.62(n)(4)
Importer Security Filing violation $5,000 for each violation §113.62(j)
Electronic advance air or truck cargo information not provided in the manner and time required, where the importer elected to file it $5,000 for each violation §113.62(k)(2)
Entry summary not filed on time The entire amount of a single entry bond; under a continuous bond, the amount that would have been demanded under a single entry bond 19 C.F.R. §142.15

CBP decides whether a default involves merchandise, and the claim is based on the quantity and value CBP determines, using the customs valuation statute, 19 U.S.C. §1401a (§113.62(n)(2)). The regulation also allows “such other amount as may be authorized by law or regulation,” so read the notice for the provision CBP actually cites.

Three quick calculations

  1. A returned payment. An ACH debit for $12,000 in estimated duties fails. The claim is two times the unpaid amount: $24,000. If the unpaid amount were $300, the claim would be the $1,000 minimum. The duties themselves are still owed.
  2. A missed redelivery. CBP makes a timely demand for goods valued at $40,000, and the importer cannot return them because they were sold. The claim is $40,000. If the goods are restricted merchandise, it is $120,000.
  3. Two late security filings. Two ISFs are filed late on two shipments. The claim can be $5,000 for each violation, $10,000 in total.

The clock: what happens after the notice

  1. Day 0: the notice is mailed. The principal and the surety are both notified (§172.1(a)).
  2. Within 60 days of mailing: file a petition for relief with the FP&F office named in the notice (19 C.F.R. §172.3(a), (b)). The FP&F officer may extend the time when circumstances warrant, so ask in writing before the deadline (§172.3(c)).
  3. A shorter deadline is possible. If fewer than 180 days remain before the statute of limitations could be raised as a defense, the notice may set a shorter period, but not less than 7 working days (§172.3(e)). Read the deadline printed on your notice instead of assuming 60 days.
  4. If the principal does nothing, or does not comply with a decision on time, CBP demands payment from the surety, which then has 60 days from that demand to file its own petition (§172.4).
  5. CBP’s decision. A decision to cancel the claim on payment of a stated amount is generally good for no more than 60 days from the date of notice, unless the decision gives a different period. If you neither pay nor file a supplemental petition in that time, the full claim is deemed applicable again and is sent on for collection and possible referral to the Department of Justice (§172.21).
  6. Supplemental petition. If you are not satisfied, you may file a supplemental petition within 60 days from the date of notice of the decision, whether or not you have paid the mitigated amount (§172.41). It is reviewed first by the FP&F officer and then, if no further relief is given, at a higher level (§172.42).

What a petition must contain

No particular form is required. The petition must state the date and place of the violation and the facts and circumstances that justify cancellation or mitigation. It must be signed by the petitioner, an attorney or a customs broker; electronic signatures are accepted. CBP may require documents to be in English or accompanied by a translation. A false statement in a petition can be prosecuted under 18 U.S.C. §1001 (19 C.F.R. §172.2).

Congress authorized cancellation of a bond charge on payment of a lesser amount, and directed that guidelines be published so decisions are uniform, reasonable and equitable (19 U.S.C. §1623(c)). CBP publishes those guidelines as an Informed Compliance Publication, Mitigation Guidelines: Fines, Penalties, Forfeitures and Liquidated Damages, with separate chapters by type of claim, including one for entry and duty claims, one for redelivery and notices of refusal, and one for late petitions. Before you write, find the chapter that matches the bond condition cited in your notice and address the factors it lists. In practice a strong petition does three things:

  • Tests whether the breach happened at all. Was the redelivery demand made within the 30-day limit in §113.62(d)? Was the entry summary in fact filed on time? Was the payment rejected because of a bank or system error? The FP&F officer may cancel a case without any payment when it is definitely determined that the act or omission behind the claim did not occur (§172.11(b)).
  • Shows what was done to cure it. Proof of later filing, payment, marking, export or destruction, with dates.
  • Explains the cause and the fix. How the error occurred, the importer’s compliance record, and what changed so that it will not recur.

Attach the documents; do not just describe them. Entry records, ACE reports, broker correspondence, bank confirmations, bills of lading and warehouse records are usually more persuasive than argument.

Paying, compromising or contesting

Three points are easy to miss:

  • A mitigation decision cannot be protested. A decision to cancel a claim on payment of a lesser amount is not a protestable decision under 19 U.S.C. §1514, and a payment made under it is not a charge or exaction (§172.22(a)).
  • Payment usually ends the matter. Paying the mitigated amount is treated as an election of administrative proceedings and as an accord and satisfaction of the government’s claim. It does not bar a supplemental petition (§172.22(b)).
  • An offer in compromise is a separate route. An offer under 19 U.S.C. §1617 must say expressly that it is made under that section, the amount offered must be deposited with CBP, and the offer is accepted only when CBP says so in writing (19 C.F.R. §§172.31, 172.33).

If the claim is not resolved, the United States can sue the principal and the surety on the bond. The Court of International Trade has exclusive jurisdiction over a civil action by the United States to recover on a bond relating to the importation of merchandise (28 U.S.C. §1582(2)). A contract action by the government must generally be filed within six years after the right of action accrues, or within one year after a final decision in a required administrative proceeding, whichever is later (28 U.S.C. §2415(a)). In court the importer can raise defenses that the petition process did not accept, but the amount at stake is then the full claim. Once a matter has been referred to the Department of Justice, CBP takes no further action on a petition and forwards it there (§172.13(a)). When less than one year remains on the limitations period, CBP may require a waiver of the statute of limitations before it accepts a supplemental petition (§172.43).

What the surety will do

The principal and the surety are jointly and severally bound on the bond (§113.62(a)(1)). The surety receives the notice when you do, and it has its own rights: 60 days to petition after CBP’s demand on it (§172.4), and 180 days from the mailing of a demand against its bond to protest when it has an unsatisfied legal claim (19 U.S.C. §1514(c)(3)). CBP can stop accepting bonds from a surety that is significantly delinquent without just cause (19 C.F.R. §113.38(c)), so sureties tend to pay valid claims.

After paying, a surety normally looks to the importer for reimbursement under the indemnity terms of the bond application, and may ask for collateral or decline to renew the bond. Check your own agreement. Tell your surety and your broker early what you are filing, and send them a copy of the petition, so they do not pay a claim you are still contesting.

A history of claims also affects the bond itself. In deciding whether a bond amount is sufficient, CBP considers the principal’s record in honoring bond commitments, including the payment of liquidated damages (19 C.F.R. §113.13(b)(5)). If CBP finds a bond inadequate, the principal has 15 days from notification to remedy the deficiency, and CBP may require additional security in the meantime (§113.13(c), (d)).

Common questions

My broker made the mistake. Do I still owe the claim?

The bond is yours, so the claim is made against you and your surety. The broker’s role is relevant to the petition and to any claim you may have against the broker, but it does not move CBP’s claim to the broker.

Is this the same as a penalty notice?

No. A liquidated damages claim arises from the bond contract and does not require proof of fault. A §1592 penalty requires a material false statement or omission and at least negligence. CBP can pursue both on the same entry.

Can I ignore the notice and wait?

That is the costly choice. CBP will demand payment from the surety, the surety will look to you, and the chance to seek cancellation for a lesser amount on your own facts narrows.

Does paying the mitigated amount admit a violation?

The regulation treats payment as an accord and satisfaction of the government’s claim (§172.22(b)). It closes the claim. Whether it matters for other purposes depends on the facts, and is worth asking counsel before you pay.

When to call a lawyer

Call when the claim is based on the value of the goods, when CBP’s demand may have been late or the breach may not have occurred, when several claims arrive together, when the surety has already been asked to pay, or when the same facts could also lead to a penalty. Attorney Cynthia Wu handles customs matters personally, in English and Mandarin, and is admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade. Phone consultations: (520) 358-5095 or book online.

Related: CBP Form 4647 notice to mark or redeliver · How §1592 penalties work · CBP protests · CBP detentions, seizures and penalties guide

Sources: 19 U.S.C. §§1401a, 1514(c)(3), 1617, 1623; 28 U.S.C. §§1582(2), 2415(a); 18 U.S.C. §1001; 19 C.F.R. §§113.13, 113.38, 113.62, 142.15, 172.1–172.4, 172.11, 172.13, 172.21, 172.22, 172.31, 172.33, 172.41–172.43. Current as of November 2026.

Attorney advertising. General information, not legal advice. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Grace, our virtual intake assistant

Initial inquiry

Start by telling Grace what happened

Grace is our virtual intake assistant. She asks general questions about your matter — what happened, when, and any notices or deadlines — and can help you book a consultation. She does not provide legal advice.

Book a consultation