In short
A §1592 case usually comes in two letters. First a pre-penalty notice: you have 30 days from the date it was mailed to answer in writing and orally (19 C.F.R. §162.78). Then, if CBP goes ahead, a notice of penalty: a petition for relief is due within 60 days of mailing (19 C.F.R. §171.2). The notice states whether CBP thinks the violation was fraud, gross negligence or negligence, and that label sets the maximum penalty. Your first answer is your best chance to lower it.
What §1592 covers
Section 1592 of the Tariff Act prohibits entering or introducing goods into the United States by means of a material false statement, document or act, or a material omission, through fraud, gross negligence or negligence (19 U.S.C. §1592(a)). Typical facts: undervalued invoices, a wrong country of origin, transshipment to avoid tariffs, a misdescribed product that changes the tariff classification, or unreported assists and royalties. A clerical error or mistake of fact is not a violation unless it is part of a pattern of negligent conduct (§1592(a)(2)).
The penalty is separate from the duty. Whatever happens to the penalty, CBP can also demand the duties, taxes and fees it lost (§1592(d)).
The two letters, and which one you have
- Date of mailing The 30-day response period runs from this date (19 C.F.R. §162.78(a)). Extensions can be requested in writing.
- Entries and merchandise Check each one: your goods, the right quantities and values.
- Laws and regulations violated CBP must list them all. Answer each one.
- Culpability Fraud, gross negligence or negligence. This sets the maximum penalty and is the heart of the response.
- Loss of revenue and proposed penalty Check CBP's math first, then whether the proposed penalty is set at the ceiling.
Timeline
- Pre-penalty notice received
- Within 30 days: written response, plus an oral presentation if requested
- CBP issues a penalty claim, or drops the case
- Within 60 days: petition for relief; supplemental petition within 60 days of the decision
- Still unresolved: the government must sue in the Court of International Trade
1. Pre-penalty notice. Before it issues a penalty claim, CBP must send a written notice that describes the merchandise and the entries, cites every law and regulation it says was violated, discloses the material facts, states whether it considers the violation fraud, gross negligence or negligence, states the estimated loss of duties, taxes and fees and the proposed penalty, and gives you a chance to respond (19 U.S.C. §1592(b)(1)(A)). No pre-penalty notice is required for noncommercial importations or where the penalty claim is $1,000 or less (§1592(b)(1)(B)).
2. Notice of penalty (penalty claim). If CBP is not persuaded, it issues the penalty claim. From here the administrative remedy is a petition for relief to the Fines, Penalties and Forfeitures office named in the notice.
Read the top of the letter carefully. “Pre-penalty” or “notice of intent to issue a claim” means the 30-day response window. “Notice of penalty” or “claim” means the 60-day petition window.
Deadlines
- Response to a pre-penalty notice: 30 days from the date of mailing. You may make one written and one oral presentation in that time (19 C.F.R. §162.78(a)). If less than a year remains on the limitation period, CBP may set a shorter period, but not less than 7 days.
- Extensions: available on written request when at least a year remains on the limitation period (§162.78(b)). Ask early and in writing.
- Petition after a penalty claim: within 60 days of mailing of the notice of penalty (19 C.F.R. §171.2).
- Supplemental petition: if you are not satisfied with the decision, within 60 days from notice of the decision, unless the decision sets another time (19 C.F.R. §171.61).
- Limitation period: the government must sue within five years after the violation, or, for fraud, within five years after it discovers the fraud (19 U.S.C. §1621). CBP often asks importers to sign a waiver of the statute of limitations to keep a case open. Do not sign one without advice: it can help keep the administrative process going, but it also gives up a defense.
Fraud, gross negligence, negligence: why the label matters
The maximum penalty depends on the level of culpability CBP alleges (19 U.S.C. §1592(c)):
- Fraud: up to the domestic value of the merchandise.
- Gross negligence: up to the lesser of the domestic value or four times the lost duties, taxes and fees; if no duty was lost, up to 40 percent of the dutiable value.
- Negligence: up to the lesser of the domestic value or two times the lost duties, taxes and fees; if no duty was lost, up to 20 percent of the dutiable value.
These are ceilings, not the amount you will necessarily pay; CBP applies published mitigation guidelines (19 C.F.R. part 171, Appendix B). But moving a case from gross negligence to negligence, or from negligence to “clerical error,” changes the range. Much of a good response is about the facts that show what the company knew, what systems it had, and why the error happened.
Who has to prove what also differs. In a fraud case the government must prove it by clear and convincing evidence; in a gross negligence case the government bears the burden; in a negligence case the government must show the act or omission, and then the importer must show it was not negligent (§1592(e)).
What to do in the first week
- Calendar the deadline from the mailing date, not the day the letter reached you.
- Collect the entry file: CBP Form 7501s, commercial invoices, purchase orders, payment records, packing lists, bills of lading, origin documents, broker correspondence and any CF-28 or CF-29 that came before.
- Check CBP’s math: the entries listed, the claimed loss of duties, and the domestic value used.
- Find out what really happened: who prepared the invoices, who gave the broker the classification or value, and whether the same issue affects entries CBP has not listed.
- Do not contact the supplier or change documents in a way that could look like covering up. Keep everything as it is.
- Ask for an extension in writing if you need more time to gather records.
Writing the response
A pre-penalty response should answer each allegation in the notice and explain why the claim should not issue, or should issue for a lower amount (19 C.F.R. §162.78(c)). In practice that means:
- Correcting factual errors in CBP’s description of the goods, entries or values.
- Showing the correct duty owed, with documents, and whether any loss of duty exists at all.
- Explaining the company’s compliance steps, the reason for the error, and what has changed since, to support a lower level of culpability.
- Pointing out mitigating factors recognized in the guidelines, such as cooperation, an otherwise good record, and immediate remedial action.
- Requesting an oral presentation if the case turns on how the business actually works.
Pay the lost duties when it is clear they are owed. Tendering the duty is often part of resolving the case, and §1592(d) allows CBP to collect it regardless.
Prior disclosure: if CBP has not found it yet
If you discover a problem before CBP starts a formal investigation, a prior disclosure can sharply limit the penalty (§1592(c)(4)). For negligence or gross negligence, the penalty is limited to interest on the unpaid duties, if the unpaid amount is tendered at the time of disclosure or within 30 days after CBP calculates it. For fraud, it is limited to an amount equal to the lost duties, or 10 percent of the dutiable value if no duty was lost. Once you have a pre-penalty notice, the investigation has usually begun, but related entries CBP has not identified may still qualify. Ask before you file anything.
If the case is not resolved
CBP cannot simply take the money. If you do not pay the penalty claim, the government must sue in the Court of International Trade to collect it (28 U.S.C. §1582). The court decides the facts and the amount anew; it is not bound by CBP’s administrative view.
An example
A Los Angeles importer of furniture receives a pre-penalty notice alleging gross negligence: for two years its invoices omitted a design fee paid separately to the overseas factory, and CBP estimates US$180,000 in lost duties. The proposed penalty is four times that amount. With counsel, the importer gathers the contracts and payment records, shows that some of the fees related to goods never imported, recalculates the loss of duties at a lower figure, documents that its broker was never told about the fees and that the error came from a new staff member’s misunderstanding, and explains the new procedure it adopted. The response asks CBP to treat the case as negligence and tenders the corrected duties. This is an illustration of how the issues fit together, not a description of a real case or a prediction of any result.
Frequently asked questions
Can I ignore a pre-penalty notice and wait for the claim?
You can, but you give up the best opportunity to change CBP’s view of culpability before it is fixed in a penalty claim. Responding costs nothing to file with CBP and is often the most effective step.
Will the goods be seized?
A §1592 case is usually about goods already entered. Seizure is possible in some situations, but most §1592 matters are money claims. A valid prior disclosure means the merchandise is not seized (§1592(c)(4)).
Is my customs broker responsible?
The importer of record is responsible for reasonable care in what it gives CBP. A broker can be liable for its own conduct, but CBP usually pursues the importer. Whether the broker’s error helps lower your culpability depends on what you told the broker and when.
Should I sign a waiver of the statute of limitations?
Sometimes it is the price of more time to negotiate; sometimes it gives away a defense. It depends on how much time is left and how strong the case is. Get advice before signing.
When to call a lawyer
Call as soon as you receive a pre-penalty notice. The first 30 days decide the shape of the case. Attorney Cynthia Wu handles each customs matter personally, in English or Mandarin, and is admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade. Consultations are by phone: (520) 358-5095 or book online.
Related: CF-28 and CF-29: what to do · CBP Notice of Detention · CBP seizure petitions for relief
Sources: 19 U.S.C. §§1592, 1621; 19 C.F.R. §§162.78, 171.2, 171.61 and part 171, Appendix B; 28 U.S.C. §1582. Current as of November 2026.
Attorney advertising. General information, not legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Part of the guide: CBP Detentions, Seizures and Penalties: A Guide for Importers

