In short
Before you hire a customs lawyer, ask who will do the work, whether they are admitted to the Court of International Trade, what your exact deadline is, what all of your options are, how the fee works and what it excludes, and what happens if CBP says no. Have your notice, entry documents and broker contact ready for the first call. Walk away from anyone who promises a result, calls themselves a “specialist” without certification, or wants payment before reading your notice.
When CBP holds your goods or sends you a notice, you usually have days, not weeks, and you may be talking to three or four lawyers at once. Most importers have never hired a customs lawyer before, so they judge by the website and the first phone call. These are the ten questions I would ask if I were in your position, and what a straight answer sounds like. Ask them of us too.
1. Who will actually work on my matter?
Ask whether the lawyer you are talking to will read the notice, write the response and talk to CBP, or whether it goes to someone else. Either can work, but you should know. In a seizure or a detention the details decide the outcome, and something gets lost every time the file changes hands.
2. Are you admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade?
A petition to CBP does not require a lawyer at all. A lawsuit does. Customs and tariff cases, including IEEPA refund cases, go to the Court of International Trade in New York, and a company has to appear there through an attorney admitted to that court. If your matter might end up in court, ask now. Changing lawyers halfway costs time you may not have.
3. What is my deadline, exactly, and what happens if we miss it?
A good lawyer will find the date on your notice and count from it while you are still on the phone. Seizure notices generally allow 30 days from the mailing date to petition or make an election (19 C.F.R. §171.2(b)). A CF-28 usually allows 30 days. A protest must be filed within 180 days of liquidation (19 U.S.C. §1514(c)(3)). If the lawyer cannot tell you the date, or says not to worry about it, keep looking. You can check a date yourself with our CBP deadline calculator.
4. What are all of my options, and which one would you choose?
A seizure notice usually lists several paths: a petition for relief, an offer in compromise, abandonment, or sending the case to court. Each has a different cost and timeline. A good answer names each option, says which one the lawyer would pick for your facts and why, and tells you what you give up. Be wary of anyone who goes straight to one answer without asking what happened.
5. Have you handled matters like mine recently?
Ask about recent matters of the same kind: same agency, same type of notice, similar goods. A lawyer cannot tell you about other clients’ confidential details, but can describe the kind of work, how those matters went, and what made the difference. In California, any results a lawyer shares should come with the reminder that past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
6. How do you charge, and what is not included?
Get the fee structure in writing before work starts: flat fee, a fee per stage, or hourly with an estimate. Then ask what sits outside it: court filing fees, service costs, translations, lab testing, storage and demurrage, and whether a later stage such as court costs extra. Surprises usually come from what was left out, not from the headline number.
7. How quickly will you respond when something happens?
In a detention, a day can matter. Ask how soon you will hear back after you send something, and who you contact if the lawyer is in court. A firm that takes two days to return the first call will probably not get faster later.
8. How will you work with my customs broker?
Your broker has the entry records and the history, and usually has to be involved. Ask whether the lawyer will coordinate with the broker directly, and whether there is any conflict between your interests and the broker’s, for example if the broker made the error. Brokers cannot represent you in court, and their interests are not always the same as yours.
9. Can you explain this to me and my team in our language?
If your managers or your supplier work in another language, ask whether the lawyer can explain the issues and the documents directly in that language. Supplier documents in Chinese, Vietnamese or Spanish are common in customs cases, and so are misunderstandings that come from them.
10. What happens if CBP says no?
Ask what the next step is after a denial. A petition decision can usually be followed by a supplemental petition within 60 days (19 C.F.R. §171.61). After that, depending on the matter, there may be a protest or a lawsuit. A lawyer who has thought about the second step before taking the first will make better choices in the first.
Questions to add for your type of matter
Goods detained
Ask what CBP is likely looking for (admissibility, another agency’s rules, forced-labor concerns, intellectual property or valuation), what documents would answer it, and what happens if CBP makes no decision. Under 19 U.S.C. §1499(c), if CBP does not decide within 30 days after the goods are presented for examination, they are treated as excluded and the importer can protest. A lawyer should know whether and when to use that.
Goods seized
Ask whether a petition, an offer in compromise or a referral to court fits your facts, what evidence the petition needs, and what the storage and liquidated-damages exposure looks like while you wait. Ask how the lawyer will deal with the Fines, Penalties and Forfeitures office at your port.
A penalty notice
For a prepenalty or penalty notice under 19 U.S.C. §1592, ask which level of culpability CBP alleges (negligence, gross negligence or fraud), whether a prior disclosure was possible or still is, how the penalty might be mitigated under CBP’s guidelines, and what the statute of limitations is (generally 5 years, 19 U.S.C. §1621). Ask whether CBP has asked you to waive the statute of limitations and what that means.
IEEPA tariff refunds
Ask which of your entries can still go through CAPE or a protest and which need a lawsuit at the Court of International Trade, what exactly the fee covers and where the lawyer’s work stops, and what your broker will need to do after a court order. A clear answer separates the court work from the broker’s later filings.
FDA refusals
Ask whether the problem is labeling, registration, a prior notice issue or the product itself, whether the goods can be reconditioned, and how the FDA hearing and CBP’s timeline fit together.
Have this ready for the first call
- The notice itself, with the envelope or the date it arrived;
- the entry number, bill of lading or air waybill, commercial invoice and packing list;
- your importer of record name and number, and your broker’s contact;
- a short timeline in your own words: what was shipped, from where, and what CBP has said;
- any earlier letters with CBP, FDA or other agencies about the same goods or supplier.
With these in hand, a lawyer can usually tell you your deadline and your real options in the first conversation.
What a good engagement letter covers
- Exactly what the lawyer will do and where the engagement ends;
- the fee and what it excludes, including court and service costs;
- who in the firm works on the matter;
- how you will communicate and who you contact;
- what happens if the matter goes to a next stage, such as court.
In California, a lawyer must generally put a fee agreement in writing when the fees are expected to exceed US$1,000 (Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code §6148), and a contingency fee agreement must always be written (§6147).
An example
The following is a hypothetical example, not a real case.
An e-commerce importer has a shipment seized at LAX and calls three firms. The first offers to “get the goods back in two weeks” for a fee paid today. The second asks for the notice, counts 30 days from the mailing date while on the phone, explains that a petition, an offer and a court referral are possible, recommends a petition supported by supplier records and a lab report, gives a written flat fee that excludes lab and storage costs, and explains the supplemental petition if the first is denied. The third never calls back. The importer hires the second firm: not because it promised more, but because it promised less and explained everything.
Red flags
- A promise of a result or a timeline. No lawyer controls what CBP or a court decides.
- A claim to be a “specialist” without a certification. In California, a lawyer may say they are a certified specialist only if certified by the State Bar or an accredited organization (Cal. Rules of Prof. Conduct, rule 7.4).
- Pressure to pay before anyone has read your notice.
- A non-lawyer company offering to “file in court” for you.
- No written engagement letter.
- Vague answers about who will do the work or what the fee excludes.
- Advice to ignore a CBP notice or “wait and see” past a deadline.
How we answer these questions
Attorney Cynthia Wu works on each matter personally, in English or Mandarin, and is admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade and the U.S. Tax Court. Consultations are by phone. For Court of International Trade cases seeking IEEPA refunds on liquidated entries, the fee is a flat US$10,000 per importer of record plus court and service costs, as described on our tariff refunds page. In 2025 we helped importers obtain the release of more than US$10 million in detained goods, and in 2026 we recovered seized goods through petitions for relief and obtained several reliquidation orders from the Court of International Trade. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Attorney advertising. General information, not legal advice. Sources: 19 C.F.R. §§151.11, 171.2(b), 171.61; 19 U.S.C. §§1499(c), 1514(c)(3), 1592, 1621; Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code §§6147, 6148; Cal. Rules of Prof. Conduct, rule 7.4. As of November 2026.
Part of the guide: CBP Detentions, Seizures and Penalties: A Guide for Importers

